Pdf moving ahead in protecting freshwater resources. I turn to the international law commissions ilc 2001 draft articles on the responsibility of states for internationally wrongful acts and 2006 draft articles on diplomatic protection. So it is important to research on draft articles on diplomatic protection in order to protest our countrys nationals whose rights were infringed upon by another country for violating international law in accordance with general. Ilc articles on responsibility of states for internationally wrongful acts 2004. The report, which also contains commentaries on the draft articles, will appear in yearbook of the international law commission, 2006, vol.
Diplomatic protection conducted by a state at interstate level remains an important remedy for the protection of persons whose human rights have been violated abroad. This article makes a case for the emergence of such a right to consular assistance in capital cases for nationals of states which have abolished the death penalty. Exercising diplomatic protection the fine line between. The ilc has however decided not to endorse this view and has rejected the use of force as a means of diplomatic protection. Next to the right of abode, entitlement to diplomatic protection was the. Extract from the report of the international law commission on the work of its fiftythird session.
Apr 01, 2006 for their part, the ilcs draft articles on diplomatic protection are even more receptive to diplomatic protection against third states. As states tend to classify certain actions as falling within consular assistance rather than diplomatic protection. The fiction underlying diplomatic protection has been subject to debate in the ilc. The diplomatic protection of refugees by their state of. Text adopted by the international law commission at its fiftyeighth session, in 2006, and submitted to the general assembly as a part of the commissions report covering the work of that session. Internationally wrongful acts, the ilc draft articles on diplomatic protection and the ilc draft articles on responsibility of international organisations and apply those provisions to practical situations. The former special rapporteur on diplomatic protection provides an accessible and very helpful overview of the topic in the online edition of the most authoritative encyclopedia of international law. Diplomatic protection becomes more difficult, however, where the ren. Refworld draft articles on responsibility of states for. The present article on diplomatic protection is not a description of the draft articles on diplomatic protection, adopted by the ilc at first reading in june 2004. It was adopted by the general assembly on 16 december 2005 in its 60th. Articles on responsibility of states for internationally wrongful acts 2001 appendix 2.
Statement on diplomatic protection, international liability. Where one state renders to a second country an individual who is a national of a third nation, international law permits that third country to intervene, seeking relief for the rendered person. Articles on diplomatic protection 2006 march 31, 20 what does diplomatic protection mean. The convention on the law of the nonnavigational uses of international watercourses was adopted by the united nations general assembly on may 21, 1997. The ilc edited and interspersed the united states comments with the comments of other states in state responsibility. This paper discusses ilc draft article 8 on diplomatic protection. Pdf nationality and diplomatic protection researchgate. Protecting recognized geneva convention refugees outside.
Nationality and diplomatic protection springerlink. Thus, when examining issues of the genuine link between a vessel and its flag state, it consulted the ilcs 1956 draft articles on the law of the sea. See report on the work of the international law commission during its 48th. Chapter two the institution of diplomatic protection 1. The position has now changed, with the adoption of the draft articles on the responsibility of states for internationally wrongful acts draft articles by the international law commission ilc in august 2001. The ilc adopts the draft code of crimes against the peace and security of mankind martin c. John dugard, diplomatic protection and human rights. The ilc articles on diplomatic protection should have specified that also the state of. Use of diplomatic protection to prosecute perpetrators of xenophobic attacks in south africa.
Dugard, john diplomatic protection and human rights. And in assessing whether the exhaustion of local remedies was required in this case, the tribunal relied on the ilcs draft articles on state responsibility. The report, which also contains commentaries on the draft articles, appears in official records of the general assembly, sixtyfirst session. Largely along the lines of the ilc articles, dugard also discusses issues of diplomatic protection in the context of international organizations. See the ilc draft articles on diplomatic protection 2006 art 1. The report, which also contains commentaries on the draft articles, appears in.
Using the url or doi link below will ensure access to this page indefinitely. In what follows, the term action with respect to diplomatic protection will be analysed through a discussion of legal writing, international and national decisions and the ilc draft articles on diplomatic protection. A6110, at 94 2006, which has eventually been endorsed, in part, by the icj in 2012 in diallo case concerning ahmadou sadio diallo guinea v. Diplomatic protection is undoubtedly an important tool in human. Exhaustion of local remedies in international investment law. The text of the draft articles with commentaries thereto adopted by the commission at its fiftyeighth session are reproduced below. Ilc draft articles on diplomatic protection, 2006 the concept of stateless persons under. Draft articles on diplomatic protection, with commentaries 2006. Draft articles on prevention of transboundary harm from. Ii exercising diplomatic protection the fine line between litigation, demarches and consular assistance introduction one of the last draft articles that was proposed by the special rapporteur. Although the purposes of both practices are to assist a national abroad, a series of critical differences exist between them. It is very important to understand the adoption of the draft code within. Diplomatic protection, which has been confirmed in different cases of the permanent court of international justice and the international court of justice, is a. The ilc itself recommended an initial resolution taking.
First, diplomatic protection is only engaged once an internationally wrongful act has. Adopted by the international law commission at its fiftythird session 2001. Diplomatic protection of dual nationals in the european journal of. Diplomatic protection in international law and the united. Diplomatic protection analytical guide to the work of. United nations legal counsel participates in the 57th annual session of the asianafrican legal consultative organization in tokyo, japan learn more. Draft articles on the responsibility of international organizations 2011 appendix 3.
Ilc articles on responsibility of states for internationally wrongful acts. United nations convention on jurisdictional immunities of states and their property. I wonder about the legal status of the draft articles made by the i. The ilc adopts the draft code of crimes against the peace. International law commission adopted the articles on diplomatic protection. At its sixtyfirst session, the general assembly took note of the draft articles on diplomatic protection, adopted by the international law commission at its fiftyeighth session, in 2006, and. P art t wo n ationality c hapter i g eneral p rinciples article 3 protection by the state of nationality 1. Apr 28, 2017 table of reports of special rapporteurs of the ilc on state responsibility for internationally wrongful acts. In the last 30 years, individuals have increasingly filed complaints against their national governments for failure to exercise diplomatic protection on their behalf, in particular in cases of serious violations of international human rights law.
Comments on ilc draft articles on state responsibility volume 95 issue 3. The ilc draft articles, aiming to codify diplomatic protection in an international treaty, link it with the notion of state responsibility. The text of the draft articles adopted by the commission at its fiftythird session with commentaries thereto is reproduced below. Pdf the ilcs articles on responsibility of states for. Oct 20, 2010 sixtyfifth general assembly sixth committee 16th meeting am legal committee discusses ways to apply law commission draft articles on diplomatic protection. Ilc draft articles on nationality of natural persons.
Impact of the ilc draft articles on responsibility of states. Peel, the ilcs draft articles on state responsibility. The ilc itself recommended an initial resolution taking note of the articles, with subsequent consideration after a period of years of a possible diplomatic conference with a view to concluding a. Prevention of transboundary harm from hazardous activities general commentary 1 the articles deal with the concept of prevention in. Draft articles on diplomatic protection with commentaries 2006 text adopted by the international law commission at its fiftyeighth session, in 2006, and submitted to the general assembly as a part of the commissions report covering the work of that session a6110.
Completion of the second reading article pdf available january 2001 with 1,494 reads how we measure reads. Text adopted by the international law commission at its fiftythird session, in 2001, and submitted to the general assembly as a part of the commissions report covering the work of that session a5610. The ilcs articles on responsibility of states for internationally wrongful acts. Diplomatic protection 1 the drafting of articles on diplomatic protection was originally seen as belonging to the study on state responsibility. Should a requirement of clean hands be a prerequisite to. Apr 28, 2017 draft articles on diplomatic protection 2006 text adopted by the international law commission at its fiftyeighth session, in 2006, and submitted to the general assembly as a part of the commissions report covering the work of that session. Instead it describes the salient features of diplomatic protection in the sense in which the term is used in the present draft articles. Any views expressed are solely those of the author or publisher.
A request to reconsider draft article 1 particularly in the light of thefictioncamefromtheitaliangovernmentandwassupportedbyanumber of ilc members. The application of the draft articles on diplomatic protection in the ahmadou sadio diallo case, 20 leiden j intl l 2007. On the whole, we view as positive the text of these draft articles. Borchard, the diplomatic protection of citizens abroad, new york 1919, at 448. Show full abstract or multiple nationalities, in spite of the fact that its scope has been curtailed by the draft articles on diplomatic protection laid down by the international law commission. Unhcr is not responsible for, nor does it necessarily endorse, its content. International legal doctrine borchard indicated that states have a choice of means for the exercise of diplomatic protection. At the time, barcelona traction provided in some respects a pro. According to the ilc articles on the responsibility of states for internationally. The ilc s articles on responsibility of states for internationally wrongful acts. Feb 17, 2009 fabbricotti, alberta, the diplomatic protection of refugees by their state of asylum a few remarks on the exclusion of the state of nationality of the refugee from the adressees of the claim february 12, 2009. The report, which also contains commentaries on the draft articles, appears in official records of the. Introduction when, on 5 july, 1996, after many years, the draft code of crimes against. I wonder about the legal status of the draft articles made.
Oxford university press online resource centre 1992 2017. It results from the general legal personality of every state under international law, and from the fact that states are the principal bearers of international obligations see also states, fundamental rights and duties. United nations convention on jurisdictional immunities of states and their property 2006. Text adopted by the international law commission at its fiftyeighth session, in 2006, and submitted to the general assembly as a part of the commissions. See draft articles on diplomatic protection, draft article 1. Diplomatic protection, which has been confirmed in different cases of the. Comments on ilc draft articles on state responsibility. The ilcs articles on responsibility of states for internationally. Rather, it is an evaluation of the draft articles and the extent to which they advance human rights, from the perspective of the special rapporteur responsible for initiating them. The commission considered the report of the drafting committee and adopted on first reading a set of 19 draft articles on diplomatic protection, with commentaries. For their part, the ilc s draft articles on diplomatic protection are even more receptive to diplomatic protection against third states. Then enter the name part of your kindle email address below.
In recent years,the area of diplomatic protection has been the subject of much work by the ilc,who produced a set of draft articles on diplomatic protection in 2006. The entire set of draft articles adopted on second reading is a compilation of the rules of customary international law governing diplomatic protection, and, in certain aspects, also reflects a gradual evolution of international law. The draft articles are a combination of codification and progressive development. Draft articles on responsibility of states for internationally wrongful acts, with commentaries. Ilc draft principles on the allocation of loss in the case of transboundary harm arising out of hazardous activities. The commission further decided that the drafting committee consider elaborating a provision on the connection between the protection of ships crews and diplomatic protection.
Draft articles on diplomatic protection, with commentaries. The state entitled to exercise diplomatic protection is the state of nationality. Internationally wrongful acts the ilc draft articles on. The article concludes that old rules precluding protection in a contest between two states of nationality are. International law, diplomatic protection, refugee law, human rights. In this statement before the 6th committee of the unga, the chinese representative comments on the ilcs draft articles on diplomatic protection and draft principles on the allocation of loss in the case of transboundary harm arising out of hazardous activities. The wrongfulness of an act of a state not in conformity with its international obligations to another state is precluded if and to the extent that the act constitutes a countermeasure directed towards the latter state under the conditions set out in articles 50 47 to 55 48. Ii exercising diplomatic protection universiteit leiden. We are also pleased that the draft articles honor the established principle of continuity of nationality as a prerequisite to the exercise of diplomatic protection on behalf of natural and corporate persons in articles 5 and 10 and, by implication, in articles 7 and 8. Jurisprudence and commentary of the au human rights bodies. Refworld draft articles on diplomatic protection with. Legal committee discusses ways to apply law commission draft. Part ii thus sets out the empirical background against which the practices of contemporary international investment tribunals may be assessed.
902 519 434 803 347 1481 1476 709 332 569 878 1358 275 1003 819 29 1016 994 1265 139 522 1409 495 1395 865 916 406 1134 816 767